What is the important educational need that you are seeking to address? This element is fundamental in this project. Since we have limited time, energy, and resources, cool technology without a clear sense of why it matters or what we gain by it is of little value in the educational setting.
The students in my Algebra 1 and Geometry classes use scientific calculators as a tool to aid in their problem solving. They use calculators to perform calculations that would be tough and tedious to do by hand due to the complexity of numbers and/or the number of calculations involved. Calculators allow students to find solutions to difficult problems. Students also use calculators to verify their solutions to problems. I want to note that I do not promote calculator use when it is not necessary. It is important that students understand when it is necessary to use a calculator and when they can perform calculations mentally, so as to not become reliant on calculators.
There are a two main errors that occur most often in Algebra and Geometry when using a scientific calculator:
1. Errors that occur when parentheses are needed:
-When dividing by the whole denominator
- Calculating roots
- Calculating exponents
2. Rounding errors
It is vital that all math students are able to use calculators as a tool to help them solve problems. Whether students are in algebra or geometry (or a higher level math class) students will run into problems in which they will need a calculator to solve. In order to use calculators productively, students must know and understand the calculators operations, what it can do and how to make it perform the operation you want it to. The problem that I need to address is that many students in my classes do not know how to properly use a calculator when dealing with parenthesis and rounding. If students don’t know how to correctly use their calculators, it can be hurtful to them. Often times students will type numbers and symbols in the calculator to find a solution to a problem, however they enter the buttons incorrectly, resulting in an incorrect result. My students have come to trust the calculator and believe that it never lies, hence it will always give them the correct answer, but they don’t realize that a calculator is programed to do what they tell it to do, which is at times something incorrect. This is an issue that needs to be resolved because it is very important for students to know how to use a calculator in order to succeed in Algebra 1, in their future math classes and also on standardized tests.2.How you plan to address this educational issue with technology? You need to make a clear and convincing case that your proposed solution will make a real impact on the issue you identify, and that your proposed approach is a reasonable approach given its costs and possible alternatives.
Logistics of solution: For example…
What is the scope? (e.g., when and where will tool be used and for how long? Who all will use it?)-
The Smart Board activity will take place in my classroom during one or two class periods. I will begin by using the Smart Board while each student will have a scientific calculator in hand. I will then progress through the lesson and have students tell me which buttons to hit in order to solve certain problems. I will also ask students to come to the board and solve problems using the scientific calculator on the Smart Board. Every student will use a scientific calculator and it will be my goal to have each student come up to the Smart Board and solve a problem for me to observe.
Relevant research and resources (from the Internet and elsewhere) including reports on the closest effort you can find to what you are planning to do as well as ideas and materials you may be able to build upon in your own effort. Your description should include:
- The results of your search (What resources may help guide your project? What resources may help in the implementation of your project?)
- What you learned from performing this search. For example, which search engines did you use? What strategies did you use? What helped or hindered your search? How would you search again next time?
A plan for the portion you will implement during this course and the portion you will implement after this course completes.
The activity that I will be creating for this project is going to be implemented at the beginning of each school year. It will be given over a day or two during the first week of school. Since the school year is coming to an end I am already aware of which students struggle at times when using a calculator and with what problems they struggle, so I will eliminate the pretest. I will implement my lesson that shows students on the Smartboard how to properly use a scientific calculator, and then I will do a posttest to see if students improved from the lesson.How would you know you were successful?
I plan to address this issue through the use of my Smart Board. One thing that I have never set aside the time to do with my students is demonstrate how to correctly use a scientific calculator. A good way to do this is to project a scientific calculator on the smart board and perform operations on the calculator for the class to observe. I will work through many different problems on the board that involve using a scientific calculator and show everyone how to correctly find solutions to these problems. This activity will be best if it is done at the beginning of the school year so the issue can be addressed from the start.
I have a Smartboard in my classroom and I also have a set of scientific calculators. This approach is a reasonable solution because I have the technology necessary available to me. It is a good alternative to solving this problem, because I can show the whole class at one time through the Smart Board how to use a scientific calculator, and students can discuss the calculators operations as a whole class. Students will also have to do some individual practice, however I will need to use the Smart Board to demonstrate to all students how to properly use a scientific calculator and answer any questions that students have.
I do believe that this solution will make an impact on students because this will be something that they have not had explained to them before, especially as a whole class assignment. Most students learn how to use a calculator through practice, and while some students have had individual help from myself or other math teachers, the objective of this activity is to show all students how to properly use a calculator. This activity will hopefully make students confident when using a calculator instead of having to figure it out on their own and assume that they are using it correctly.
I have a Smartboard in my classroom and I also have a set of scientific calculators. This approach is a reasonable solution because I have the technology necessary available to me. It is a good alternative to solving this problem, because I can show the whole class at one time through the Smart Board how to use a scientific calculator, and students can discuss the calculators operations as a whole class. Students will also have to do some individual practice, however I will need to use the Smart Board to demonstrate to all students how to properly use a scientific calculator and answer any questions that students have.
I do believe that this solution will make an impact on students because this will be something that they have not had explained to them before, especially as a whole class assignment. Most students learn how to use a calculator through practice, and while some students have had individual help from myself or other math teachers, the objective of this activity is to show all students how to properly use a calculator. This activity will hopefully make students confident when using a calculator instead of having to figure it out on their own and assume that they are using it correctly.
3.
I used a few different search engines during my search, such as Google, Google Scholar, Yahoo, MSU Library’s e-resources and delicious.com (thanks for the help Michelle and Nancy). I had a difficult time at the beginning my search because I was trying to find resources that researched the exact same thing that I am trying to implement. I realized that I wasn’t having too much success, and I started breaking down my search into different aspects of my project. I will explain each resource that I found, what I searched to find it, and how I might use it in my project:
1. I first began looking for an online scientific calculator that I can use to project to the class. My classroom uses TI-30x ISS calculators. TI offers a free download of their TI-83 graphing calculator to use on your computer, however they don’t offer it for the TI-30. It has been difficult to find this exact calculator to project to the classroom, so I am going to have to do things a bit different from how I originally planned.
I will use the TI-83 graphing calculator and also this scientific calculator online http://my.hrw.com/math06_07/nsmedia/tools/Sci_Calculator/Sci_Calculator.html while demonstrating some of the things I want to share with the class (such as exponents and parenthesis). For rounding and storing answers, I will use parts of the teacher’s guide below. It shows pictures of the calculator, points out specific buttons and lists the buttons that needed to be hit in order to store answers.
2. Next I researched the Texas Instrument website because I figured that the company who created the calculator would have some good resources for it, and I found a few good things here:
-Quick Reference Card: http://education.ti.com/downloads/guidebooks/scientific/30xii/TI-30XII_QRC.pdf
-Tutorials: http://learningmedia.ti.com/public/media/ti34/index.html
-Activities that use the calculator: http://education.ti.com/calculators/downloads/us/Activities/Search/Subject?s=5022&d=1002
-I found a guidebook for teachers, that has tutorials and activities for students. When you click on this link it is blank, but I saved the pdf to my computer and the content was there.
http://education.ti.com/downloads/guidebooks/scientific/30xii/teacher_guide/30xiitg-eng_.pdf
-A card similar to the quick reference card:
http://www.actuarialoutpost.com/downloads/ti30xii-qr.pdf
3. I also researched specifically for lessons that have been created using a scientific calculator, and I found 2 different websites, one of which came from the TI website:
http://www.doe.virginia.gov/instruction/mathematics/middle/scientific_calculator_lessons.pdf
http://education.ti.com/educationportal/sites/US/nonProductSingle/activitybook_30xiis_activities.html
4. Then I found a couple lessons that were created to teach students how to use the scientific calculator that I can modify and use in my lesson, and they are below:
-Click here to view a powerpoint that helps students with order of operations and exponents.
-Here is a website that teaches students about order of operations: http://staff.argyll.epsb.ca/jreed/math7/strand1/1203.htm
5. Then I began searching for educational resource about the problems/solutions with scientific calculators, resources for smart boards and also how smart boards are beneficial to student learning. Below is what I found:
Issues with Scientific Calculators: http://ezinearticles.com/?Using-a-Scientific-Calculator-In-Mathematics-Exams&id=148783
Resources for Smart Boards: http://its.leesummit.k12.mo.us/smartboard.htm
Benefits of Smart Boards: http://downloads01.smarttech.com/media/research/international_research/canada/interimfindings_unbresearchbrief.pdf
1. I first began looking for an online scientific calculator that I can use to project to the class. My classroom uses TI-30x ISS calculators. TI offers a free download of their TI-83 graphing calculator to use on your computer, however they don’t offer it for the TI-30. It has been difficult to find this exact calculator to project to the classroom, so I am going to have to do things a bit different from how I originally planned.
I will use the TI-83 graphing calculator and also this scientific calculator online http://my.hrw.com/math06_07/nsmedia/tools/Sci_Calculator/Sci_Calculator.html while demonstrating some of the things I want to share with the class (such as exponents and parenthesis). For rounding and storing answers, I will use parts of the teacher’s guide below. It shows pictures of the calculator, points out specific buttons and lists the buttons that needed to be hit in order to store answers.
2. Next I researched the Texas Instrument website because I figured that the company who created the calculator would have some good resources for it, and I found a few good things here:
-Quick Reference Card: http://education.ti.com/downloads/guidebooks/scientific/30xii/TI-30XII_QRC.pdf
-Tutorials: http://learningmedia.ti.com/public/media/ti34/index.html
-Activities that use the calculator: http://education.ti.com/calculators/downloads/us/Activities/Search/Subject?s=5022&d=1002
-I found a guidebook for teachers, that has tutorials and activities for students. When you click on this link it is blank, but I saved the pdf to my computer and the content was there.
http://education.ti.com/downloads/guidebooks/scientific/30xii/teacher_guide/30xiitg-eng_.pdf
-A card similar to the quick reference card:
http://www.actuarialoutpost.com/downloads/ti30xii-qr.pdf
3. I also researched specifically for lessons that have been created using a scientific calculator, and I found 2 different websites, one of which came from the TI website:
http://www.doe.virginia.gov/instruction/mathematics/middle/scientific_calculator_lessons.pdf
http://education.ti.com/educationportal/sites/US/nonProductSingle/activitybook_30xiis_activities.html
4. Then I found a couple lessons that were created to teach students how to use the scientific calculator that I can modify and use in my lesson, and they are below:
-Click here to view a powerpoint that helps students with order of operations and exponents.
-Here is a website that teaches students about order of operations: http://staff.argyll.epsb.ca/jreed/math7/strand1/1203.htm
5. Then I began searching for educational resource about the problems/solutions with scientific calculators, resources for smart boards and also how smart boards are beneficial to student learning. Below is what I found:
Issues with Scientific Calculators: http://ezinearticles.com/?Using-a-Scientific-Calculator-In-Mathematics-Exams&id=148783
Resources for Smart Boards: http://its.leesummit.k12.mo.us/smartboard.htm
Benefits of Smart Boards: http://downloads01.smarttech.com/media/research/international_research/canada/interimfindings_unbresearchbrief.pdf
I will give a pretest and posttest to students before and after the activity. These tests will contain the types of problems that students struggle with due to calculator errors. Based on the results I can see who struggled in the pretest and who improved with the posttest.
I completely agree that it is crucial to teach students early on how to correctly use the scientific calculator. we have the same situation with our Algebra 1 and Geometry students. I have a Smart-View TI-84 loaded on my laptop that can be used on the Smartboard. It is an extremely useful tool when teaching students how to appropriately use the Graphic Display Calculator. Students can see the exact buttons we push and how the screen should look. I like your idea of implementing this project at the beginning of every school year to ensure that students understand the correct way of using the scientific calculator. It could also be something that you revisit regularly throughout the year whenever there is a need.
ReplyDeleteThe calculator problem. I love it. I have actually done some research on the ways students use calculators to solve problems and the results that they get. As part of an internship year course project, I did a study of how students perform on problems involving parentheses when using or not using a calculator. We had students complete a problem set without a calculator first. Then months later, so they would not remember the problems, we gave them the same set, but encouraged calculator use. The results were surprising to say the least. There were many students that solved the problem correctly by hand following order of operations, but then made mistakes on the same problems when using a calculator incorrectly, especially in the use of parentheses. It's a complex problem, but also a common one. I still have juniors in my high school math classes fail to type things in their calculator correctly. I think your solution of starting off the school year with a lesson on how to use calculators is a great idea. Maybe you could also include some kind of cheat sheet for how to type in some common expressions (Do This vs. Not This). This also might be something to review at the beginning of every year or before upcoming tests like the ACT. I'm excited to hear how this goes for you!
ReplyDeleteSarah
I think the proper use of the calculator is a vital part of their success within their math classes and when it comes to the ACT!! I think this is a great project to work on 'showing' the students how to properly enter things into the calculator. I find the use of parenthesis to be such an issue not only on the scientific calculator, but they still have their problems while using the graphing calculator! I love the use of the 'SmartView' calculator on my interactive whiteboard when demonstrating how to enter things on the calculator!
ReplyDeleteI'm very interested to see your findings, but I think this is a great problem to focus on! The lesson at the beginning of the year, and reminders throughout, whether posted on the wall, in their agenda, or on a cheat sheet would be a great help! The sooner they learn these vital lessons, the sooner they will stop making these mistakes and apply the mathematics properly!
Can't wait to hear how this goes!